Fire Island, United States of America

No dates selected

Sort by

Price per night in

Distance from the city center

Hotels in Fire Island

: 35 options found

Select dates so you can see the availability and exact prices.

3845 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ronkonkoma
15.6 km from the center of Fire Island
356 reviews
4.6

Room in this hotel

from $ 136
per night
3055 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ronkonkoma
15.6 km from the center of Fire Island
79 reviews
6.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 136
per night
3485 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Ronkonkoma
15.6 km from the center of Fire Island
1380 reviews
9.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 195
per night
915 Sunrise Highway, North Babylon, NY 11704, United States of America, North Babylon
17.1 km from the center of Fire Island
10 reviews
5.6

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
1630 Lakeland Avenue, Bohemia
15.5 km from the center of Fire Island
19 reviews
4.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
300 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore
14.5 km from the center of Fire Island
26 reviews
3.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
10 Aero Rd, Bohemia
15.3 km from the center of Fire Island
995 reviews
7.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 133
per night
501 East Main Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States of America, Bay Shore
11.5 km from the center of Fire Island

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
7 Courthouse Drive, Central Islip
13.6 km from the center of Fire Island
190 reviews
8.4

Room in this hotel

from $ 266
per night
25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770, USA, Fire Island
861 m from the center of Fire Island
205 reviews
7.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 265
per night
478 Bayberry Walk, Fire Island
923 m from the center of Fire Island
101 reviews
7.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 350
per night
576 South Service Road, Patchogue, NY 11772, United States, Patchogue
16.7 km from the center of Fire Island
1 review
2.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
501 E Main Street, Bay Shore
11.4 km from the center of Fire Island
94 reviews
5.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 105
per night
785 Evergreen Walk Ocean Beach Fire Island New York 11770 Suffolk County, Fire Island
807 m from the center of Fire Island
11 reviews
6.0

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
168 Cottage Walk, Fire Island
1 km from the center of Fire Island
917 reviews
8.6

Room in this hotel

from $ 307
per night
1 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, Fire Island, NY 11782, Fire Island
4.9 km from the center of Fire Island
63 reviews
9.6

Room in this hotel

from $ 170
per night
11 Courthouse Dr., Central Islip
13.6 km from the center of Fire Island

Room in this hotel

from $ 246
per night
69 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore
11.3 km from the center of Fire Island

Room in this hotel

from $ 463
per night
22 Atlantic Walk, Fire Island
6.7 km from the center of Fire Island

Room in this hotel

from $ 207
per night
501 E Main Street, Long Island, New York 11706, Bay Shore
11.5 km from the center of Fire Island

Room in this hotel

from $ 192
per night
1